Stainless Tubing vs Stainless Pipe Difference

10/11/2023

Image Description: Welded Stainless Tubing

It's easy to understand why most people struggle when differentiating between stainless tubing and stainless pipes. After all, both of these items look very similar. However, it is important to recognize the difference between them as their use cases are different. Choosing the incorrect item for your application may have drastic consequences and may even drive up the cost of your projects. Here are some key differences between the two.

Measurement and Ordering

Stainless tubing is generally used for applications where structural support is required. This can include roll cages in cars, making monkey bars for your playground, or fabricating the support structure of a rig for hoisting. These applications require precise dimensions for the outer diameter (OD) of the tubing so that each part of the fabricated structure fits correctly. The wall thickness (WT) depends on the strength of the structure required so it doesn't bend or break when forces are exerted upon it.

On the other hand, piping is required to carry fluids throughout a process, such as those in chemical and petroleum processing plants. Here the internal diameter (ID) is more important as it specifies the fluid carrying capacity of the vessel and the flow rate, crucial to pipe sizing calculations for projects. The OD for pipes comes in standard sizes called the nominal pipe size (NPS). Additionally, the wall thickness is specified by the schedule of the pipe, important for determining the pressure rating of the pipe. The outer diameter and wall thickness enable you to calculate the internal diameter and order appropriately sized pipes with a certain strength.

Shapes and Size

Due to fluid exerting equal pressure on the walls of their vessel; any other shape other than circular would not be suitable for piping. In contrast, tubes can be manufactured to have different cross-sectional shapes other than a circle, like rectangular or ovular.
Additionally, stainless pipes can approach 80 inches in diameter, while stainless tubing only comes close to 5 inches.


Manufacturing

Since the OD of stainless pipes doesn't matter as much as their ID, they don't require laborious processes to make sure their outer appearance is perfect. On the other hand, stainless tubing has to undergo strict tolerance checks to make sure it fulfills strict guidelines for strength, shape, and appearance. These additional processes make stainless tubing more costly as compared to a stainless pipe of the same weight. It is for the same reason stainless piping can be mass-produced and delivered to customers easily.

Materials

Depending on the application, stainless tubing is most commonly used in structures requiring durability, aesthetics, or corrosion resistance. Hence, it needs to be made out of alloy steels that exhibit these characteristics, like 304 and 316, or variants within these grades. On the other hand, stainless pipes are most commonly used in the medical and food industry, where sanitary concerns are the utmost priority. Hence, a wider range of alloys in the 300 series can be used, depending on the pH, mass flow rate, and reactivity of the material they carry.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between stainless steel tubing and stainless steel pipe?

Stainless steel tubing and pipe differ primarily in how they are measured, specified, and used. Tubing is typically ordered by its exact outside diameter (OD) and wall thickness, making it suitable for precision instrumentation, hydraulic systems, and structural applications. Pipe is generally specified by nominal pipe size (NPS) and schedule, with emphasis on fluid transport and flow capacity. Tubing is available in round, square, and rectangular shapes, while industrial piping is typically round.

What is the difference between welded and seamless stainless steel tubing?

Welded stainless steel tubing is manufactured by forming stainless steel strip into a tube and joining its edges with a longitudinal weld. Seamless tubing is produced from solid steel stock without a longitudinal weld seam. Both types are used in industrial applications, but seamless tubing is often selected for demanding pressure and temperature conditions, while welded tubing can offer cost and availability advantages. Actual pressure capability depends on applicable standards, wall thickness, material grade, and manufacturing quality.

What is the difference between 304 and 316 stainless steel tubing?

Both 304 and 316 stainless steel tubing provide strength, durability, and corrosion resistance. Grade 304 contains chromium and nickel, making it suitable for many general industrial and processing applications. Grade 316 also contains molybdenum, which improves resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion in many chloride-containing environments. For coastal, marine, or certain chemical-processing applications, 316 is often preferred, while 304 may be a more economical choice for less corrosive environments.

What are the advantages of 304L and 316L stainless steel tubing?

Grades 304L and 316L are low-carbon versions of 304 and 316 stainless steel. Their reduced carbon content helps minimize chromium carbide precipitation during welding, reducing the risk of corrosion near welded joints. This makes them useful for welded tubing assemblies, instrumentation systems, and industrial processes where corrosion resistance is important. Grade 316L also offers improved resistance to many chloride-containing environments compared with 304L.

Is seamless stainless steel tubing better for high-pressure applications?

Seamless stainless steel tubing is frequently selected for high-pressure applications because it does not contain a longitudinal weld seam. However, properly manufactured and rated welded tubing can also perform reliably under pressure. The maximum allowable pressure depends on tubing dimensions, material strength, temperature, applicable standards, and fitting compatibility. Customers should verify the manufacturer's published pressure ratings rather than assuming seamless tubing is always stronger than welded tubing.

How do dual-ferrule instrumentation tube fittings work?

Dual-ferrule instrumentation fittings use two ferrules, a front ferrule and a back ferrule, to create a secure mechanical connection between tubing and the fitting body. As the fitting nut is tightened, the front ferrule forms the primary seal while the back ferrule grips the tubing to resist movement and pullout. This design provides reliable connections for properly specified industrial instrumentation, fluid handling, and high-pressure applications.

What is the purpose of the back ferrule in a dual-ferrule tube fitting?

The back ferrule provides mechanical tubing grip and helps maintain connection integrity in a dual-ferrule instrumentation fitting. During installation, it is driven against the tubing to develop a secure hold, helping the fitting resist vibration, pressure loads, and tubing movement. Back ferrules are often engineered with controlled hardness and material properties to provide effective gripping performance. Proper installation and material compatibility are essential for reliable operation.

How do you select the correct stainless steel tubing and fittings for an industrial application?

Selecting stainless steel tubing and fittings requires evaluating operating pressure, temperature, fluid compatibility, corrosion exposure, tubing outside diameter, and wall thickness. Grade 304 is suitable for many general industrial environments, while 316 or 316L may be preferred for more corrosive conditions. Welded and seamless tubing should be evaluated according to applicable pressure ratings and manufacturing standards. For instrumentation connections, properly matched dual-ferrule fittings can provide secure, leak-resistant performance when installed according to manufacturer specifications.

More questions: Tubing

10/11/2023